They did apache vs gladiator over the weekend. Apache won over 60% mainly due to range - the bow. 30% of the time if the glad got within 6' the net and trident won. Knight should be interesting depending on what armor stage. Gun powder effectively killed off armor which gives range and mobility to pirate. Hand to hand Knight would win. Then again depends on terrain - non armored archers kicked fully armored knights on a muddy field in france.